Postpartum8 min read

Postpartum depression vs baby blues: how to tell the difference

Leanne Sawchuk

By

Morning sun rising over a frosted meadow, the way sadness in the first few days can lift, unlike depression that stays.

It's day four, and your mental state feels like a stranger's. Someone hands you toast, and you cry. An hour later you're laughing at something your baby did, and by dinner you feel close to tears again for no reason you can name. You wonder if this is normal, or if something is wrong. If you'd like support, we offer postpartum depression therapy in Kitchener-Waterloo, in person or online anywhere in Ontario.

Two things often get mixed up in the early postpartum days: the baby blues and postpartum depression, often shortened to PPD. One usually passes by itself, and the other needs care. If you're wondering about the inside experience of depression, our earlier article on what postpartum depression feels like goes deeper. This article looks at how the two differ, how long each tends to stay, and when it's worth checking in with someone about your mental health.

What the baby blues feel like

The baby blues show up for many new mothers in the first few days after the birth. You might notice that you feel weepy, moody or easily overwhelmed, often without a clear trigger. Mood swings are a big part of it. Happy one minute, in tears the next.

It can feel confusing, especially when you love your baby and things are going fairly well. Why am I crying over toast? is a very ordinary postpartum thought.

The blues often come with anxiety about small things and feeling anxious or impatient with the people around you. Your body is healing from pregnancy and childbirth, your hormones are shifting after delivery, and sleep deprivation adds to all of it. Feeling up and down in the postpartum period is expected.

Common blues symptoms in the first weeks

They tend to show up in a handful of familiar ways:

  • Tearful. Tears come quickly, often over small things.
  • Up and down. Your mood swings from light to low in the same afternoon.
  • Overwhelmed. A feed and a shower can feel like too much.
  • Irritable. Small noises grate.
  • On edge. Anxiety has you checking on your baby's breathing again and again.
  • Worn out. Not just short on sleep, but mentally and emotionally drained, with trouble sleeping even when you can.

As a rough guide, blues symptoms tend to ease within a fortnight or so. They usually fade a little more each day, and for most people they go away on its own schedule, without treatment. You may also hear them called postpartum blues.

How postpartum depression is different

Postpartum depression is not just a stronger version of the blues. It lasts longer, it sits deeper, and it starts to affect how you function day to day in postpartum life.

Instead of passing waves, the low mood stays, sometimes for weeks after the birth. Many people with PPD feel sad most of the day, or flat and empty rather than sad. There can be a loss of interest in things that used to bring joy, and the sadness doesn't lift on the good days. Your baby may be thriving and feeding well while you feel worse each week. Some people feel a heavy hopelessness, or feel worthless, or carry heavy guilt about not feeling the way they think a new mother should feel.

It can also make bonding feel harder, or leave you feeling far away from your baby, and it can make it hard to care for your baby or care for yourself in the way you want to. You might feel depressed and still get every feed done. I'm doing everything, so why do I feel like this?

Anger and anxiety can be part of it too. Irritability that doesn't settle, a short fuse and a constant sense of being on edge are worth noticing.

Depression symptoms that last longer

Some of the ways depression can show up across the postpartum months:

  • low mood most days, from the moment you wake up
  • losing interest in things that used to matter
  • a harsh inner voice, and a sense of shame that you're failing
  • changes in sleep or appetite, even when your baby is settled
  • finding it hard to concentrate or decide
  • fatigue that runs deeper than a rough night

These depression symptoms overlap with ordinary life with a newborn, which is part of why the two get confused. The difference is in how many weeks they stay, how heavy they feel, and how much they get in the way.

The difference between baby blues and postpartum depression

A side-by-side look can help you sort out what you're feeling in these postpartum days:

  • Timing. The blues usually start in the first days postpartum. PPD can start in pregnancy, soon after the birth of your baby, or later in the postpartum period.
  • Length. The blues rarely last more than a couple of weeks. Depression lingers and often gets heavier without help.
  • How deep it goes. The blues come in waves with good moments between them. Depression feels more constant, with fewer breaks, and the sadness has a weight that doesn't shift.
  • Daily life. The blues are hard, but you can usually keep going. Depression makes daily tasks and connection with your baby feel much harder.
  • What helps. Time, help with the baby and a few good nights often ease the blues. Postpartum depression vs baby blues comes down to this: depression usually needs more, including a check-in about your health and support such as therapy.

When sad feelings don't lift

Sad feelings that hang on are worth taking seriously. It's a good idea to reach out to your family doctor or midwife if:

  • the low mood isn't easing with time
  • things are getting worse rather than better
  • it's hard to eat or settle even when you have the chance
  • it's hard to look after yourself or your baby
  • you have thoughts of harming yourself or your baby: contact a doctor or emergency services right away

You may hear the wider term perinatal depression, which covers depression during pregnancy and in the postpartum year. Postpartum anxiety can show up alongside the baby blues or depression, and it's worth mentioning too. Your provider can also look at your physical health, since some things in the postpartum body can affect mood. Your health matters here as much as your baby's. Your care team can give you clear information about the difference, and it's okay to ask for help before you're sure.

Is it the blues, or something more?

It can be hard to tell. The early postpartum stretch is a blur for most new parents, and there isn't always a clear line between baby blues or postpartum depression. You might have baby blues that seem to drag on, or low postpartum days mixed with okay ones.

This often shows up when people try to talk themselves out of how they feel. Everyone's tired. Everyone cries. Maybe, but it's still worth checking. Asking whether it's baby blues or PPD isn't something you need to settle on your own.

Two questions about your health can help: how many days has this been going on, and how much is it getting in the way? If the answer is "a while now" and "a lot", it's time to talk to someone about your postpartum mental health and your overall health.

Getting through the postpartum weeks

Whether it's the blues or the start of something heavier, a few basics ease the mental and physical stress of postpartum life. Rest when you can, even in short stretches. Eat something regular. Get a bit of daylight. Let family take a feed so you can sleep, and add some light exercise, like a short walk, when you can.

Practical help with a new baby makes a real health difference and takes some stress off. Asking for support is part of caring for your baby. Ask your partner, family or friends for a meal or an hour to yourself. Breastfeeding or bottle feeding, healing from childbirth and caring for a newborn all take a lot, and it's okay to need people. Every parent needs support in the postpartum period.

It also helps to keep an eye on your health, and your baby's health, as the weeks go on. Your baby needs you rested and fed, and so does your own health. A postpartum check with your care team is a good time to mention how your mood has been, not just how your body is healing from childbirth. Recovery isn't only physical.

Where to find support for PPD

If it looks more like depression than the blues, there's good support available. A public health nurse is a good first step, and many communities have a postpartum clinic or a support group for new mothers. These health resources can give you reliable information about what to expect after pregnancy, information about your options, and a place to talk with mothers who understand.

Talk therapy is one of the most widely used ways people work through PPD and care for their health after a baby. In therapy, we can look at what you're feeling without judgment, ease the self-blame, and find small steps that help you feel more like yourself. Counselling can happen in person or online. For some people, treatment also includes medication that they discuss with their prescriber.

Other resources matter too: good information from your healthcare provider, family support at home, and other new moms who have been there. Postpartum mental health care is as important as postpartum care for your body, and your mental and emotional health deserve the same support as your physical health.

Depression doesn't only start right after the birth. Our next article looks at when postpartum depression happens, including later in the first year.

Frequently asked questions

They can overlap. Some people start with the baby blues, and the low mood doesn't lift. If the feelings last past the early postpartum days or get heavier, it's worth talking to someone in your health care team.

Leanne Sawchuk
About Leanne Sawchuk, RP
Leanne is a Registered Psychotherapist with more than 12 years of clinical experience and the founder of our practice in Kitchener-Waterloo. She works relationally and somatically with anxiety, trauma, depression, grief, relationships and addictions. She is trained in Somatic Experiencing and the Gottman Method, and is a Certified Trauma Informed Practitioner (CTIP).